Old Lyme Market Report

or Create your own market report

Below is a list of active properties, properties under contract, and recent sold properties for the past six months.

Stay on top of the market by signing up to get updated version of this market report delivered directly to your inbox. Or create your own customized market report using the link above.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
5-1 Pilgrim Landing Road 6 8 5,158 $7,200,000 $1,395 155 days
1 & 3 Neck Road 4 4 6,742 $4,100,000 $608 316 days
43 Smiths Neck Road 4 4 1,539 $3,250,000 $2,111 293 days
2 Lyme Street 9 9 9,029 $2,750,000 $304 8 days
10 Longacre Lane 5 6 7,980 $2,495,000 $312 24 days
311-3 Ferry Road 3 3 2,302 $2,349,900 $1,020 34 days
2-4 Bank Road 4 3 2,080 $2,299,000 $1,105 29 days
6 Johnny Cake Hill Road 3 4 6,492 $2,000,000 $308 14 days
108 Sill Lane 4 5 5,283 $1,550,000 $293 75 days
1 Seaside Lane 3 2 1,774 $1,425,000 $803 206 days
3-2 Bill Hill Road 4 4 4,462 $1,300,000 $291 250 days
88 Grassy Hill Road 3 3 2,434 $1,150,000 $472 89 days
7 Bittersweet Lane 4 4 2,821 $895,000 $317 23 days
3-1 Huntley Road 4 3 4,361 $849,000 $194 27 days
37-2 West End Drive 3 3 2,918 $849,000 $290 35 days
29 Mccurdy Road 2 2 2,072 $745,000 $359 21 days
14 Olivia Lane 3 3 2,471 $665,000 $269 14 days
194 Mile Creek Road 3 3 2,289 $565,000 $246 29 days
6-1 Myrica Way 3 3 3,204 $550,000 $171 7 days
29 4 Mile River Road 4 3 2,984 $500,000 $167 0 days
13 Browns Lane 3 2 2,656 $499,900 $188 14 days
2 Wyckford Lane Unit 2 2 3 1,684 $498,000 $295 14 days
63 Portland Avenue 2 1 482 $489,900 $1,016 27 days
42 Swan Avenue 5 2 1,602 $475,000 $296 141 days
3 Homestead Circle 3 2 2,267 $460,000 $202 0 days
2 Katherine Road 3 2 1,836 $459,900 $250 14 days
1 Columbus Avenue 2 1 816 $449,999 $551 55 days
48 Browns Lane 3 2 1,530 $429,900 $280 8 days
45 4 Mile River Road 3 3 1,537 $409,000 $266 62 days
32 Portland Avenue Unit 2 3 1 739 $405,000 $548 19 days
14 Homestead Circle 3 1 1,063 $309,900 $291 7 days
Average: 3.5 3.2 3,051 $1,366,883 $491 65 days
Viewing 1 - 31 of 31
Viewing 1 - 31 of 31
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
87 Sill Lane 5 4 5,368 $1,995,000 $1,800,000 $335 164 days 6/10/22
12 Riverbend Road 5 5 4,233 $1,585,000 $1,585,000 $374 2 days 6/16/22
76 Lyme Street 5 7 5,423 $1,450,000 $1,250,000 $230 173 days 4/25/22
2 Brighton Road 4 4 4,438 $1,250,000 $1,180,000 $265 53 days 4/4/22
4-2 Talcott Farm Road 4 4 4,339 $1,000,000 $1,100,000 $253 0 days 5/23/22
69 Neck Road 4 4 2,836 $1,100,000 $1,040,000 $366 191 days 4/20/22
4 White Farm Lane 3 3 3,063 $965,000 $965,000 $315 0 days 6/22/22
6 Beckwith Lane 4 4 3,819 $875,000 $925,000 $242 0 days 1/25/22
4 Meetinghouse Lane 3 3 3,247 $925,000 $912,500 $281 0 days 2/28/22
15 Cottage Road 4 2 1,344 $1,099,000 $910,000 $677 216 days 3/3/22
53 Browns Lane 5 5 4,982 $869,000 $859,500 $172 105 days 2/23/22
57 Seaview Road 4 2 1,591 $809,000 $855,000 $537 0 days 1/5/22
29 Mccurdy Road 2 2 2,072 $780,000 $825,000 $398 3 days 5/18/22
6 Meetinghouse Lane 4 4 3,894 $785,000 $785,000 $201 23 days 4/29/22
22 Oak Road 4 2 1,483 $785,000 $785,000 $529 54 days 1/31/22
79-2 Rowland Road 4 4 2,970 $775,000 $780,000 $262 0 days 4/15/22
39 Sill Lane 3 3 2,317 $775,000 $775,000 $334 28 days 2/4/22
9 Matson Ridge 3 3 3,478 $749,900 $770,000 $221 0 days 1/26/22
5 Academy Lane 3 3 2,076 $639,900 $717,500 $345 0 days 2/4/22
15 Neck Road 5 3 3,344 $699,000 $699,000 $209 30 days 5/20/22
2 Lonicera Court 4 3 2,729 $585,000 $689,500 $252 1 day 5/26/22
1 Swanswood Lane 3 4 2,977 $659,000 $685,000 $230 0 days 4/8/22
29 Rowland Road 3 3 3,386 $629,000 $647,500 $191 28 days 6/24/22
12 Great Oak Road 3 3 2,309 $624,900 $624,900 $270 87 days 3/21/22
9-1 Meetinghouse Lane 4 4 3,414 $695,000 $620,000 $181 2 days 4/12/22
4 Windward Lane 4 3 3,102 $519,000 $592,000 $190 0 days 2/28/22
12 Craig Road 4 3 3,635 $575,000 $581,500 $159 43 days 6/10/22
44 Flagler Avenue 2 2 1,896 $559,000 $575,000 $303 0 days 5/3/22
20 Wildwood Drive 3 2 1,814 $495,000 $552,500 $304 0 days 5/3/22
150 Mile Creek Road 4 3 2,597 $518,000 $550,000 $211 64 days 6/30/22
6 Center Beach Avenue 3 2 1,757 $549,900 $550,000 $313 73 days 4/27/22
24 Saunders Hollow Road 3 3 2,208 $495,000 $527,500 $238 0 days 1/25/22
14 Flagler Avenue 3 1 816 $499,900 $500,000 $612 9 days 1/14/22
10 Center Beach Avenue 3 1 1,057 $477,000 $482,000 $456 1 day 6/7/22
18 Katherine Road 3 1 960 $489,900 $480,000 $500 0 days 2/16/22
18 Hefflon Farm Road 3 3 1,956 $465,000 $476,000 $243 2 days 6/24/22
246 Shore Road 4 3 2,508 $475,000 $472,500 $188 0 days 4/13/22
3 Mansewood Road 3 3 1,864 $419,000 $467,000 $250 0 days 1/7/22
1 Clifton Street 2 2 2,526 $485,000 $455,000 $180 224 days 2/25/22
43 Browns Lane 2 2 1,754 $399,900 $450,000 $256 1 day 5/6/22
5 Prospect Street 4 3 2,240 $399,900 $447,500 $199 0 days 2/26/22
453 Shore Road 3 2 1,812 $439,900 $440,000 $242 24 days 3/17/22
4 Whippletree Lane 4 2 2,535 $425,000 $435,000 $171 0 days 2/18/22
21 Chadwick Drive 4 2 2,278 $399,000 $415,000 $182 45 days 1/28/22
57 Hillcrest Road 4 2 1,010 $449,000 $410,000 $405 107 days 2/18/22
6 Bayberry Ridge Road 3 3 2,180 $375,000 $405,111 $185 2 days 4/4/22
25 Old Shore Road 5 2 1,914 $535,000 $400,000 $208 11 days 5/3/22
38 Lone Pine Trail 4 2 2,139 $419,900 $375,000 $175 11 days 5/9/22
106 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,407 $349,900 $370,000 $262 2 days 6/21/22
2 Sands Drive 3 2 2,086 $320,000 $360,000 $172 1 day 6/3/22
Average: 3.3 2.6 2,337 $613,909 $612,696 $283 28 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 62
Viewing 1 - 50 of 62

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2022 SmartMLS, Inc.