Old Lyme Market Report

or Create your own market report

Below is a list of active properties, properties under contract, and recent sold properties for the past six months.

Stay on top of the market by signing up to get updated version of this market report delivered directly to your inbox. Or create your own customized market report using the link above.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
44 Hatchett Point Road 6 6 5,124 $5,500,000 $1,073 141 days
102 Town Woods Road 5 7 6,132 $2,995,000 $488 68 days
00 Buttonball, Shore Road N/A N/A N/A $2,975,000 Unknown 1969 days
20 Smiths Neck Road 4 5 6,247 $2,150,000 $344 61 days
11 Meetinghouse Lane 5 6 6,222 $1,950,000 $313 289 days
14-1 Neck Road 5 5 6,014 $1,899,999 $315 190 days
12 Tantummaheag Road 3 3 3,426 $1,500,000 $437 4 days
184 Shore Road N/A N/A N/A $1,500,000 Unknown 1969 days
8-1 Sill Lane 3 4 4,260 $1,495,000 $350 281 days
4 Catbriar Lane 4 4 4,826 $1,200,000 $248 23 days
27-1 Mccurdy Road 4 4 3,391 $1,200,000 $353 66 days
46 Seaview Road 3 1 1,232 $1,200,000 $974 278 days
21 Buttonball Road N/A N/A 441,698 $1,200,000 $2.71 2164 days
18 Seaview Road 4 4 2,168 $1,175,000 $541 152 days
106 Lyme Street 4 4 4,671 $1,050,000 $224 41 days
37-1 Mile Creek Road 4 4 3,631 $1,050,000 $289 113 days
1 Town Woods Road 4 2 1,953 $1,000,000 $512 106 days
3-2 Bill Hill Road 3 3 2,763 $999,000 $361 470 days
32 Sill Lane 4 4 2,986 $998,000 $334 103 days
1 Sill Lane 6 4 4,260 $995,000 $233 148 days
56 Seaview Road 3 1 1,332 $959,000 $719 244 days
11 Academy Lane 5 4 4,605 $895,000 $194 45 days
47 Brighton Road 3 3 2,766 $869,000 $314 166 days
6 Tantummaheag Road 4 5 5,893 $849,900 $144 588 days
76 Lyme Street 5 6 5,500 $838,000 $152 27 days
3 Village Lane 4 4 4,012 $749,000 $186 170 days
49 Hatchetts Hill Road N/A N/A N/A $747,000 Unknown 767 days
49 Hatchetts Hill Road N/A N/A N/A $747,000 Unknown 834 days
37-2 West End Drive 1 1 2,918 $689,000 $236 68 days
37-2 West End Drive 3 3 2,918 $689,000 $236 68 days
252 Boston Post Rd N/A N/A N/A $650,000 Unknown 17 days
12 Matson Ridge 5 4 4,429 $649,000 $146 8 days
10-1 Wolcott Lane 4 4 4,063 $635,000 $156 31 days
28 Katherine Road 2 2 1,528 $612,900 $401 19 days
23 Haywagon Drive 4 3 4,011 $610,000 $152 28 days
17 Oakridge Drive 4 3 2,224 $599,000 $269 95 days
27 Champion Road 4 2 1,182 $599,000 $506 169 days
15 Edge Lea Road 4 3 2,145 $579,900 $270 352 days
26 Bailey Road 3 4 2,310 $579,000 $250 26 days
104 Mile Creek Road 3 2 2,662 $575,000 $216 27 days
45 Flat Rock Hill Road 4 3 3,177 $569,000 $179 125 days
10 Stonewood Drive 4 4 3,510 $559,000 $159 46 days
40 Portland Avenue 5 2 1,505 $549,900 $365 47 days
59 Seaview Road 2 2 956 $549,000 $574 24 days
95 Lyme Street 5 4 2,519 $549,000 $217 325 days
12 Wood Crest Drive 4 3 2,708 $547,000 $201 51 days
82 1 Boston Post Road 3 3 2,287 $499,000 $218 25 days
2 Cutler Road 3 3 2,093 $499,000 $238 52 days
1 Hawthorne Road 4 3 3,472 $495,000 $142 86 days
4 Homestead Circle 4 2 2,459 $489,000 $198 33 days
Average: 3.4 2.7 8,040 $600,229 $254 248 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 124
Viewing 1 - 50 of 124
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
12 Riverbend Road 5 5 4,233 $819,000 $193 568 days
11 Haywagon Drive 4 4 3,270 $599,000 $183 54 days
26 Walnut Road 4 2 2,280 $494,900 $217 128 days
10 Neck Road 3 3 2,220 $469,000 $211 32 days
5 Rose Lane 3 2 2,110 $459,000 $217 46 days
117 Sill Lane 4 3 2,585 $439,000 $169 49 days
15 Hefflon Farm Road 3 3 2,460 $429,000 $174 22 days
30 Jericho Drive 5 3 2,817 $405,000 $143 30 days
4 Hillwood East Road 4 4 2,500 $399,900 $159 68 days
110 Neck Road 3 2 2,434 $349,900 $143 71 days
54 Gorton Avenue 7 1 1,232 $324,200 $263 106 days
6 Hillside Road 3 2 1,446 $299,000 $206 61 days
45 Johnny Cake Hill Road 3 2 1,818 $299,000 $164 78 days
21 Moore Avenue 3 2 1,760 $285,000 $161 63 days
17 Clifton Street 2 1 864 $268,000 $310 54 days
12 Grassy Hill Road 1 1 580 $258,000 $444 306 days
14 Lake Drive 3 1 1,172 $248,000 $211 5 days
56 Whippoorwill Road 3 2 936 $245,000 $261 17 days
312 Portland Avenue Extension 2 1 1,108 $190,000 $171 158 days
30 Hartford Avenue Unit A 2 1 714 $189,900 $265 42 days
Average: 3.4 2.3 1,926 $373,490 $213 98 days
Viewing 1 - 20 of 20
Viewing 1 - 20 of 20
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
21 Talcott Farm Road 4 5 5,194 $1,350,000 $1,200,000 $231 256 days 3/22/19
25 Talcott Farm Road 4 4 3,338 $1,325,000 $1,150,000 $344 43 days 7/15/19
23 Hartung Place 5 2 1,924 $1,049,000 $920,000 $478 314 days 3/25/19
7 Sill Lane 4 4 3,459 $764,000 $737,500 $213 34 days 5/29/19
79 Hill Crest Road 3 4 1,774 $675,000 $660,000 $372 3 days 6/13/19
47 Seaside Lane 4 2 1,345 $639,000 $632,000 $469 20 days 7/10/19
7 Clarks Lane 4 4 4,059 $674,900 $615,000 $151 17 days 7/17/19
2 Swanswood Lane 4 6 3,258 $575,000 $607,000 $186 33 days 6/10/19
3 Rose Lane 4 2 2,535 $550,000 $550,000 $216 13 days 7/15/19
3 Great Oak Road 4 4 3,200 $549,900 $522,000 $163 136 days 3/25/19
9 Azalea Lane 4 4 3,193 $509,000 $499,000 $156 45 days 6/14/19
6 Saunders Hollow Road 4 3 3,116 $525,000 $495,000 $158 147 days 4/26/19
48 Swan Avenue 2 3 3,328 $499,000 $455,000 $136 87 days 6/28/19
299 Mile Creek Road 4 3 3,077 $479,000 $454,000 $147 38 days 6/28/19
10 Lyme Street N/A 6 4,013 $549,000 $450,000 $112 237 days 7/12/19
10 Lyme Street N/A N/A 4,013 $549,000 $450,000 $112 237 days 7/12/19
9 Binney Road 4 3 2,190 $468,000 $450,000 $205 104 days 2/6/19
28 Seaview Road 3 1 1,092 $499,900 $441,600 $404 54 days 7/12/19
2 Flagler Avenue 3 3 2,746 $443,000 $430,000 $156 147 days 5/3/19
13 Seaview Road 3 1 940 $439,000 $420,000 $446 14 days 6/21/19
3 Wyckford Lane Unit 3 2 2 1,733 $430,000 $418,500 $241 76 days 5/17/19
41 Breen Avenue 3 2 1,123 $429,000 $415,000 $369 33 days 5/22/19
43 Rogers Lake Trail 3 2 1,196 $424,900 $415,000 $346 85 days 4/25/19
201 Shore Road 3 3 2,699 $424,900 $415,000 $153 36 days 3/15/19
188 Mile Creek Road 3 2 1,640 $414,900 $410,000 $250 11 days 6/5/19
9 Ladyslipper Lane 4 4 2,707 $425,000 $410,000 $151 123 days 2/15/19
7 Gould Lane 3 3 2,457 $449,000 $405,000 $164 168 days 3/27/19
29 Rowland Road 3 3 3,386 $399,900 $399,900 $118 110 days 6/29/19
28 Champlain Drive 3 3 2,417 $399,900 $399,900 $165 55 days 3/22/19
14 Saunders Hollow Road 3 2 1,580 $399,000 $390,000 $246 28 days 6/10/19
312 Brightwater Road 3 2 1,333 $399,900 $385,000 $288 46 days 5/29/19
68 Old Colony Road 8 3 2,988 $399,000 $360,000 $120 44 days 3/22/19
1 Westwood Road 3 3 1,896 $359,000 $359,000 $189 36 days 5/20/19
63 Columbus Avenue 3 2 1,553 $354,900 $354,900 $228 51 days 7/16/19
69 Town Woods Road 3 3 2,198 $359,000 $350,000 $159 89 days 4/15/19
7 Tisbury Road 3 3 2,094 $349,000 $350,000 $167 0 days 3/22/19
180 4 Mile River Road 5 3 3,151 $349,900 $350,000 $111 102 days 5/3/19
18 Clifton Street 3 1 1,000 $399,900 $350,000 $350 226 days 6/27/19
53 Four Mile River Road 3 2 2,796 $339,000 $337,000 $120 23 days 6/6/19
31 Coult Lane 3 3 2,420 $349,000 $332,000 $137 44 days 3/29/19
89 Flat Rock Hill Road 3 3 1,768 $334,900 $330,000 $186 65 days 4/25/19
314 Boston Post Road 2 2 1,698 $339,000 $325,000 $191 82 days 2/5/19
177 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,188 $315,900 $314,000 $264 26 days 2/14/19
1 Shore Acres Road 4 2 1,344 $398,500 $310,750 $231 80 days 6/21/19
1 Center Beach Avenue 3 3 2,090 $320,000 $307,500 $147 49 days 5/17/19
33 4 Mile River Road 3 3 2,271 $310,000 $300,000 $132 63 days 4/26/19
97 Whippoorwill Road 4 3 2,227 $349,000 $300,000 $134 103 days 1/22/19
152 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,413 $299,900 $294,000 $208 64 days 6/17/19
247 Shore Road 3 2 1,250 $279,900 $284,900 $227 59 days 3/14/19
48 Portland Avenue 4 2 1,200 $319,000 $282,500 $235 29 days 6/7/19
Average: 3.1 2.4 1,988 $400,465 $377,231 $210 81 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 76
Viewing 1 - 50 of 76