Old Lyme Market Report

or Create your own market report

Below is a list of active properties, properties under contract, and recent sold properties for the past six months.

Stay on top of the market by signing up to get updated version of this market report delivered directly to your inbox. Or create your own customized market report using the link above.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
44 Hatchett Point Road 6 6 5,124 $3,250,000 $634 452 days
102 Town Woods Road 5 7 6,132 $2,495,000 $406 379 days
100 Lyme Street 11 14 8,888 $1,999,999 $225 265 days
14 Longacre Lane 4 5 3,968 $1,995,000 $502 0 days
15 Academy Lane 4 5 6,956 $1,550,000 $222 194 days
1 Seaside Lane 4 2 1,774 $1,495,000 $842 62 days
12 Tantummaheag Road 3 3 3,426 $1,250,000 $364 315 days
20 Smiths Neck Road 4 5 6,247 $1,200,000 $192 6 days
18 West End Drive 5 4 2,638 $1,200,000 $454 25 days
18 Seaview Road 4 4 2,456 $1,185,000 $482 146 days
40 West End Drive 3 2 1,676 $1,100,000 $656 14 days
1 Town Woods Road 4 2 1,953 $1,000,000 $512 417 days
3-2 Bill Hill Road 3 3 2,763 $999,000 $361 781 days
41 Neck Road 4 4 3,412 $998,000 $292 41 days
4 Cord Grass Lane 4 4 6,164 $789,000 $128 76 days
11 Academy Lane 5 4 4,705 $755,000 $160 139 days
6 Tantummaheag Road 4 5 5,893 $749,900 $127 899 days
16 Hartung Place 7 4 2,511 $749,500 $298 81 days
100 West End Drive 4 2 1,558 $749,000 $480 268 days
187-1 Mile Creek Road 4 5 4,969 $739,900 $148 237 days
16 Mansewood Road 2 3 1,950 $690,000 $353 67 days
103 Boston Post Road 3 3 3,023 $589,000 $194 8 days
227 Mile Creek Road 5 5 3,201 $549,900 $171 116 days
12 Craig Road 4 3 2,977 $506,500 $170 74 days
8 Somerset Lane 4 3 2,889 $489,000 $169 75 days
28 Hartford Avenue 5 3 1,528 $475,000 $310 13 days
61 Biscayne Boulevard 3 2 1,092 $474,900 $434 15 days
70 Lyme Street 3 2 1,604 $469,000 $292 81 days
34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road 3 4 2,825 $449,900 $159 14 days
168 4 Mile River Road 3 2 1,694 $430,000 $253 7 days
4 Homestead Circle 4 2 2,459 $429,000 $174 118 days
10 Johnny Cake Hill Road 2 2 1,792 $429,000 $239 417 days
8 Short Hills Road 3 3 2,214 $415,900 $187 11 days
41-2 Neck Road 3 2 1,735 $415,000 $239 0 days
29 Flat Rock Hill Road 3 3 1,878 $399,000 $212 5 days
15 Miami Avenue 3 1 792 $399,000 $503 18 days
13 5th Avenue 3 2 1,032 $369,000 $357 22 days
20 Gorton Avenue 4 2 1,452 $349,999 $241 165 days
2 Maple Lane 3 3 1,337 $349,000 $261 211 days
21 Walnut Road 2 1 768 $334,900 $436 85 days
23 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,982 $319,900 $161 60 days
29 Old Colony Road 5 2 1,360 $319,000 $234 4 days
1 Columbus Avenue 2 1 816 $299,500 $367 110 days
10 Chadwick Drive 4 2 2,065 $295,000 $142 16 days
26 Gorton Avenue 4 1 950 $289,900 $305 109 days
30 Hartford Avenue Unit C 3 2 984 $279,900 $284 81 days
11 Griswold Avenue 2 2 1,305 $264,900 $202 186 days
5 Epsilon Avenue 3 2 1,539 $262,900 $170 203 days
3 Beckwith Lane 6 2 2,493 $215,000 $86 293 days
47 Four Mile River Road 3 1 1,020 $209,900 $205 25 days
Average: 3.8 3.1 2,544 $681,705 $272 151 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 56
Viewing 1 - 50 of 56
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
14 Neck Road 4 4 6,014 $1,795,000 $298 95 days
17 Tantummaheag Road 4 4 2,814 $1,695,000 $602 23 days
13 Binney Road 4 6 5,348 $1,200,000 $224 17 days
50 West End Drive 5 2 1,168 $629,900 $539 283 days
27 Champion Road 4 2 1,182 $535,000 $452 480 days
95 Lyme Street 5 4 2,519 $449,000 $178 71 days
12 Beckwith Lane 3 2 1,553 $425,000 $273 82 days
30 Homestead Circle 3 2 1,477 $410,000 $277 71 days
21 West End Drive 3 1 864 $409,900 $474 76 days
24 Gorton Avenue 2 1 940 $389,900 $414 200 days
4 Cedar Hollow Drive 4 3 2,786 $379,000 $136 20 days
6 Corsino Avenue 3 2 1,266 $379,000 $299 32 days
35 Rowland Road 3 2 2,600 $379,000 $145 39 days
72 Connecticut Road 3 1 876 $349,900 $399 46 days
53 Boughton Road 2 2 1,176 $334,900 $284 61 days
6 Wychwood Road 3 2 2,650 $320,000 $120 11 days
56 Sill Lane 2 2 2,124 $317,000 $149 83 days
41 West End Drive 3 1 734 $299,000 $407 65 days
105 Sill Lane 3 2 1,893 $299,000 $157 80 days
65 Rogers Lake Trail 3 2 1,500 $295,000 $196 29 days
23 Mccurdy Road 3 3 1,966 $295,000 $150 75 days
22 Washington Avenue 3 1 816 $292,000 $357 67 days
130 Boston Post Road 3 1 1,589 $249,500 $157 49 days
26 Rogers Lake Trail 2 1 742 $187,500 $252 3 days
Average: 3.2 2.2 1,941 $513,104 $289 86 days
Viewing 1 - 24 of 24
Viewing 1 - 24 of 24
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
8-1 Sill Lane 3 4 4,260 $1,395,000 $1,250,000 $293 515 days 5/15/20
3 Catbriar Lane 4 5 4,774 $1,200,000 $1,200,000 $251 0 days 4/3/20
37-1 Mile Creek Road 4 4 3,118 $975,000 $953,250 $305 119 days 3/20/20
4 Catbriar Lane 4 4 4,826 $920,000 $880,015 $182 290 days 5/14/20
106 Lyme Street 4 4 4,671 $925,000 $875,000 $187 176 days 3/3/20
32 Sill Lane 4 4 2,986 $910,000 $855,000 $286 151 days 1/15/20
56 Seaview Road 3 1 1,332 $959,000 $800,000 $600 227 days 12/5/19
10-2 Ferry Road 4 3 5,015 $849,000 $785,000 $156 77 days 4/13/20
105-1 Hillcrest Road 3 2 1,195 $849,900 $732,000 $612 228 days 5/15/20
49 Browns Lane 5 5 5,487 $699,000 $699,000 $127 60 days 1/15/20
62 West End Drive 4 2 1,072 $649,000 $642,000 $598 133 days 4/24/20
305-1 Ferry Road 4 3 3,726 $639,000 $630,000 $169 87 days 4/3/20
144 Neck Road 3 3 2,328 $629,000 $617,000 $265 0 days 3/4/20
3 Village Lane 4 4 4,012 $649,000 $610,000 $152 263 days 2/14/20
3 Pyrus Court 4 4 3,917 $619,000 $604,000 $154 30 days 5/15/20
11 Wolcott Lane 4 3 4,033 $585,000 $580,000 $143 57 days 2/24/20
7 Duchess Drive 5 4 3,630 $599,000 $575,000 $158 0 days 12/20/19
12 Cord Grass Lane 4 3 3,022 $595,000 $567,500 $187 12 days 5/6/20
12 Matson Ridge 5 4 4,429 $599,000 $565,000 $127 235 days 5/8/20
23 Library Lane 3 3 2,681 $595,000 $550,000 $205 0 days 12/11/19
26 Bailey Road 3 4 2,310 $524,000 $515,000 $222 0 days 12/5/19
2 Millers Way 4 4 4,054 $529,000 $502,000 $123 0 days 1/14/20
17 Oakridge Drive 4 3 2,224 $489,000 $470,000 $211 47 days 12/6/19
9 Bayberry Ridge Road 3 3 2,590 $475,000 $462,500 $178 63 days 2/25/20
16 Johnny Cake Hill Road 3 2 2,513 $498,000 $458,200 $182 0 days 1/27/20
4 Village Lane 3 4 2,516 $465,000 $457,000 $181 59 days 3/27/20
63 Old Colony Road 9 4 3,100 $496,000 $456,000 $147 0 days 5/1/20
63 Old Colony Road Road 9 4 3,100 $496,000 $456,000 $147 0 days 5/1/20
12 Wood Crest Drive 4 3 2,708 $475,000 $455,000 $168 76 days 4/15/20
2 Holly Lane 4 3 2,699 $450,000 $436,500 $161 22 days 1/21/20
5 Pyrus Court 4 3 2,575 $460,000 $435,000 $168 143 days 5/5/20
54 Jericho Drive 4 2 3,336 $435,000 $435,000 $130 0 days 12/4/19
188 Mile Creek Road 3 2 1,414 $425,000 $417,500 $295 0 days 3/3/20
34 Johnny Cake Hill Road 4 3 3,047 $425,000 $410,000 $134 0 days 12/18/19
63 Sill Lane 4 3 2,552 $415,000 $405,000 $158 0 days 12/19/19
4 Windward Lane 5 3 3,102 $417,700 $399,900 $128 186 days 5/1/20
6 Squire Hill 4 3 3,250 $399,900 $395,000 $121 142 days 3/14/20
39 Mile Creek Road 4 3 2,637 $414,900 $390,000 $147 0 days 1/30/20
69 Whippoorwill Road 4 2 2,304 $399,000 $385,000 $167 0 days 12/23/19
15 Grassy Hill Road 3 2 2,110 $369,000 $376,500 $178 0 days 4/17/20
4 Fox Chase Lane 3 3 1,760 $369,000 $350,000 $198 138 days 3/13/20
247 Mile Creek Road 4 3 2,824 $349,000 $349,000 $123 0 days 4/2/20
5 Jean Drive 4 3 2,811 $340,200 $335,000 $119 79 days 4/27/20
9 Briar Hill Drive 3 3 2,000 $335,000 $335,000 $167 131 days 4/14/20
7 Apple Tree Lane 4 2 1,977 $334,000 $333,000 $168 22 days 4/20/20
9 Short Hills Road 3 2 1,722 $335,000 $325,000 $188 0 days 1/31/20
59-3 Rowland Road 3 3 1,556 $339,900 $322,300 $207 1 day 5/8/20
22 Grassy Hill Road 3 1 874 $345,000 $312,000 $356 0 days 12/6/19
3 Stoneleigh Knoll 4 2 2,350 $325,000 $310,000 $131 0 days 12/19/19
5 Center Beach Avenue 3 2 1,584 $319,000 $302,000 $190 3 days 4/30/20
Average: 3.6 2.8 2,464 $466,790 $443,877 $193 53 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 72
Viewing 1 - 50 of 72