Old Lyme Market Report

or Create your own market report

Below is a list of active properties, properties under contract, and recent sold properties for the past six months.

Stay on top of the market by signing up to get updated version of this market report delivered directly to your inbox. Or create your own customized market report using the link above.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
5-1 Pilgrim Landing Road 6 8 5,158 $6,850,000 $1,328 305 days
4 Lieutenant River Lane 6 5 7,386 $4,000,000 $541 72 days
1 Neck Road 4 4 6,742 $3,600,000 $533 129 days
2 Lyme Street 9 9 9,029 $2,750,000 $304 158 days
10 Longacre Lane 5 6 7,980 $2,495,000 $312 174 days
2-4 Bank Road 4 3 2,080 $2,299,000 $1,105 133 days
3 Mill Pond Lane 4 3 3,182 $1,495,000 $469 185 days
No address 5 4 5,004 $1,290,000 $257 73 days
88 Grassy Hill Road 3 2 1,550 $1,095,000 $706 75 days
7 Bittersweet Lane 4 4 2,821 $849,000 $300 173 days
11 Buttonball Road 2 1 1,058 $799,000 $755 108 days
250 Mile Creek Road 4 4 3,721 $549,900 $147 44 days
5 Noyes Road 3 2 1,200 $499,900 $416 81 days
106 Neck Road 5 3 2,105 $459,999 $218 53 days
45 4 Mile River Road 3 3 2,537 $450,000 $177 18 days
54 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,688 $385,000 $228 49 days
Average: 4.4 3.9 3,952 $1,866,674 $487 115 days
Viewing 1 - 16 of 16
Viewing 1 - 16 of 16
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
6 Johnny Cake Hill Road 3 4 6,492 $1,900,000 $1,800,000 $277 89 days 11/18/22
87 Sill Lane 5 4 5,368 $1,995,000 $1,800,000 $335 140 days 6/10/22
12 Riverbend Road 5 5 4,233 $1,585,000 $1,585,000 $374 0 days 6/16/22
37 Mile Creek Road 4 4 3,118 $1,150,000 $1,201,500 $385 0 days 9/16/22
9-1 Matson Ridge 4 4 5,185 $1,095,000 $1,075,000 $207 39 days 10/3/22
4 White Farm Lane 3 3 3,063 $965,000 $965,000 $315 0 days 6/22/22
10 West End Drive 5 3 2,184 $1,250,000 $950,000 $434 368 days 7/18/22
64 Shore Road 4 4 3,114 $949,500 $949,500 $304 2 days 9/1/22
10-2 Ferry Road 4 3 5,015 $899,000 $899,000 $179 25 days 9/29/22
19-1 Matson Ridge 4 3 3,176 $895,000 $895,000 $281 23 days 9/16/22
3 Maple Lane 3 3 1,962 $749,000 $749,000 $381 21 days 10/20/22
54 Ridgewood Road 5 2 1,577 $775,000 $740,000 $469 7 days 9/16/22
29 Mccurdy Road 2 2 2,072 $745,000 $740,000 $357 22 days 7/28/22
37-2 West End Drive 3 3 2,918 $799,000 $732,500 $251 112 days 11/7/22
8 Olivia Lane 3 3 2,873 $659,900 $729,000 $253 2 days 8/31/22
4 Berberis Drive 4 3 3,972 $650,000 $722,000 $181 0 days 10/20/22
6 Olivia Lane 3 3 2,647 $674,900 $685,000 $258 45 days 8/23/22
4 Village Lane 3 3 2,516 $729,000 $680,000 $270 8 days 8/11/22
8 Hemlock Circle 2 2 2,041 $679,000 $679,000 $332 0 days 9/13/22
62 Sill Lane 3 4 3,620 $695,000 $675,000 $186 17 days 10/31/22
24 Briar Hill Drive 4 5 3,669 $725,000 $675,000 $183 32 days 8/29/22
9 Ladyslipper Lane 4 3 2,707 $649,000 $675,000 $249 8 days 7/6/22
14 Olivia Lane 3 3 2,471 $665,000 $670,000 $271 64 days 8/23/22
10 Azalea Lane 3 3 2,622 $659,900 $659,900 $251 0 days 10/28/22
52 Connecticut Road 4 2 1,240 $680,000 $650,000 $524 42 days 10/7/22
10-2 Browns Lane 3 3 2,886 $595,000 $650,000 $225 62 days 8/15/22
29 Rowland Road 3 3 3,386 $629,000 $647,500 $191 17 days 6/24/22
40 Portland Avenue 7 3 2,225 $579,900 $591,900 $266 17 days 8/1/22
12 Craig Road 4 3 3,635 $575,000 $581,500 $159 21 days 6/10/22
150 Mile Creek Road 4 3 2,597 $518,000 $550,000 $211 59 days 6/30/22
376 Shore Road 3 3 2,858 $550,000 $550,000 $192 59 days 7/29/22
185 Mile Creek Road 4 3 3,844 $575,000 $544,250 $141 5 days 8/15/22
15 Carrington Road 3 2 975 $525,000 $535,000 $548 1 day 10/28/22
257-1 Mile Creek Road 3 2 1,976 $479,900 $525,000 $265 0 days 10/17/22
6-1 Myrica Way 3 3 3,204 $550,000 $525,000 $163 16 days 8/12/22
29 4 Mile River Road 4 3 2,984 $500,000 $523,000 $175 1 day 8/19/22
54 Swan Avenue 4 2 1,680 $589,900 $516,511 $307 36 days 7/14/22
13 Browns Lane 3 2 2,656 $499,900 $515,000 $193 78 days 9/4/22
203-1 Shore Road 3 2 1,870 $499,000 $500,000 $267 49 days 9/29/22
10 Center Beach Avenue 3 1 1,057 $477,000 $482,000 $456 0 days 6/7/22
18 Hefflon Farm Road 3 3 1,956 $465,000 $476,000 $243 0 days 6/24/22
14 Duchess Drive 3 3 3,274 $495,000 $475,000 $145 0 days 7/21/22
2 Wyckford Lane 2 3 1,684 $498,000 $465,000 $276 103 days 10/7/22
3 Homestead Circle 3 2 2,267 $460,000 $463,000 $204 27 days 9/30/22
63 Portland Avenue 2 1 482 $469,900 $460,000 $954 55 days 8/12/22
50 Browns Lane 3 3 1,652 $499,000 $460,000 $278 62 days 7/15/22
5 Wychwood Road 4 3 2,227 $469,000 $459,000 $206 13 days 8/5/22
9 Mansewood Road 3 2 1,797 $385,000 $450,000 $250 2 days 10/24/22
18 Center Beach Avenue 3 2 1,200 $485,000 $440,000 $366 21 days 11/3/22
7 Breen Avenue 3 2 961 $399,900 $440,000 $457 2 days 9/19/22
Average: 3.2 2.5 2,266 $589,356 $582,993 $287 27 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 75
Viewing 1 - 50 of 75

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2022 SmartMLS, Inc.