Old Lyme Market Report

or Create your own market report

Below is a list of active properties, properties under contract, and recent sold properties for the past six months.

Stay on top of the market by signing up to get updated version of this market report delivered directly to your inbox. Or create your own customized market report using the link above.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
44 Hatchett Point Road 6 6 5,124 $5,500,000 $1,073 24 days
102 Town Woods Road 5 7 6,132 $3,925,000 $640 255 days
00 Buttonball, Shore Road N/A N/A N/A $2,975,000 Unknown 1852 days
14-1 Neck Road 5 5 6,014 $1,999,999 $332 73 days
11 Meetinghouse Lane 5 6 6,222 $1,950,000 $313 172 days
8-1 Sill Lane 3 4 4,260 $1,570,000 $368 164 days
12 Tantummaheag Road 3 3 3,426 $1,500,000 $437 347 days
184 Shore Road N/A N/A N/A $1,500,000 Unknown 1852 days
25 Talcott Farm Road 4 4 3,338 $1,325,000 $396 13 days
46 Sea View Road 3 1 1,232 $1,200,000 $974 161 days
21 Buttonball Road N/A N/A 441,698 $1,200,000 $2.71 2047 days
18 Seaview Road 4 4 2,168 $1,175,000 $541 35 days
37-1 Mile Creek Road 4 4 3,631 $1,150,000 $316 300 days
3-2 Bill Hill Road 3 3 2,763 $1,150,000 $416 353 days
1 Sill Lane 6 4 4,260 $995,000 $233 31 days
56 Sea View Road 3 1 1,332 $989,000 $742 127 days
21 Ferry Road 4 5 4,808 $899,000 $186 186 days
6 Tantummaheag Road 4 5 5,893 $899,000 $152 471 days
12 Riverbend Road 5 5 4,233 $819,000 $193 451 days
3 Village Lane 4 4 4,012 $799,000 $199 53 days
10 Lyme Street N/A 6 4,013 $799,000 $199 202 days
10 Lyme Street N/A N/A 4,013 $799,000 $199 202 days
76 Lyme Street 5 6 5,500 $797,000 $144 116 days
7 Sill Lane 4 4 3,459 $764,000 $220 14 days
49 Hatchetts Hill Road N/A N/A N/A $747,000 Unknown 650 days
49 Hatchetts Hill Road N/A N/A N/A $747,000 Unknown 717 days
12 Matson Ridge 5 4 4,429 $679,000 $153 185 days
19 Hartung Place 4 1 1,984 $674,900 $340 46 days
62 W. End Drive 4 2 1,072 $659,900 $615 353 days
252 Boston Post Road N/A N/A N/A $650,000 Unknown 446 days
305-1 Ferry Road 4 3 3,526 $649,900 $184 360 days
10-1 Wolcott Lane 4 4 4,063 $639,000 $157 392 days
27 Champion Road 4 2 1,182 $625,000 $528 52 days
2 Millers Way 4 4 4,054 $569,000 $140 444 days
28 Sea View Road 3 1 1,092 $549,900 $503 417 days
48 Swan Avenue 4 4 3,328 $549,000 $164 17 days
48 Swan Avenue 4 5 3,328 $549,000 $164 17 days
95 Lyme Street 5 4 2,519 $549,000 $217 208 days
26 Walnut Road 4 2 2,280 $509,000 $223 11 days
4 Village Lane 3 4 2,516 $499,000 $198 93 days
34 Johnny Cake Hill Road 4 3 3,047 $480,000 $157 70 days
10 Johnny Cake Hill Road 2 2 1,792 $475,000 $265 29 days
44 Flagler Avenue 2 2 1,896 $469,000 $247 40 days
61 Neck Aka 2 Talcott Farm Road 2 2 1,667 $455,000 $272 4 days
2 Flagler Avenue 3 3 2,746 $443,000 $161 114 days
3 Wyckford Lane Unit 3 2 2 1,733 $439,900 $253 49 days
14 Ferry Road Unit E2 2 2 1,756 $439,000 $250 189 days
12 Beckwith Lane 3 2 1,553 $424,000 $273 196 days
43 Coult Lane 5 3 2,837 $405,000 $142 21 days
29 Rowland Road 3 3 3,386 $399,900 $118 63 days
Average: 3.3 2.7 8,334 $574,637 $253 290 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 115
Viewing 1 - 50 of 115
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
23 Hartung Place 5 2 1,924 $1,049,000 $545 316 days
6 Saunders Hollow Road 4 3 3,116 $525,000 $168 152 days
7 Gould Lane 3 3 2,457 $449,000 $182 168 days
43 Rogers Lake Trail 3 2 1,196 $424,900 $355 56 days
69 Town Woods Road 3 3 2,198 $359,000 $163 70 days
31 Coult Lane 3 3 2,420 $349,000 $144 44 days
89 Flat Rock Hill Road 3 3 1,768 $334,900 $189 38 days
33 4 Mile River Road 3 3 2,271 $310,000 $136 33 days
46 Four Mile River Road 2 2 1,007 $249,500 $247 189 days
312 Portland Avenue Extension 2 1 1,108 $190,000 $171 52 days
30 Hillside Road 2 1 1,014 $164,900 $162 6 days
Average: 3.0 2.4 1,861 $400,472 $224 103 days
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
21 Talcott Farm Road 4 5 5,194 $1,350,000 $1,200,000 $231 256 days 3/22/19
133-1 Boston Post Road 3 2 2,525 $749,900 $772,500 $305 126 days 1/11/19
14 Stonewood Drive 4 5 4,794 $765,000 $760,000 $158 0 days 1/7/19
4-1 Talcott Farm Road 4 4 3,792 $619,000 $619,000 $163 0 days 10/1/18
7 Duck River Lane 4 4 2,446 $545,000 $545,000 $222 0 days 11/5/18
6 Sandpiper Point Road 4 4 2,978 $549,000 $537,000 $180 95 days 12/21/18
6 Lyme Street 4 5 3,648 $550,000 $535,000 $146 57 days 10/19/18
29 Billow Road 5 2 2,069 $575,000 $510,000 $246 0 days 10/29/18
2 Lonicera Court 4 3 2,729 $485,000 $480,000 $175 0 days 11/27/18
11 Great Oak Road 3 3 2,900 $549,900 $463,046 $159 202 days 10/15/18
9 Binney Road 4 3 2,190 $468,000 $450,000 $205 104 days 2/6/19
41 Flat Rock Hill Road 4 4 3,139 $455,000 $447,500 $142 0 days 1/15/19
8 Old Stagecoach Road 3 3 2,798 $429,900 $429,900 $153 0 days 10/15/18
4 Somerset Lane 3 3 2,911 $439,000 $425,000 $145 154 days 1/9/19
201 Shore Road 3 3 2,699 $424,900 $415,000 $153 36 days 3/15/19
121 Whippoorwill Road 3 3 2,730 $419,000 $410,000 $150 0 days 10/29/18
9 Ladyslipper Lane 4 4 2,707 $425,000 $410,000 $151 123 days 2/15/19
58 & 60 Swan Avenue 5 3 1,512 $475,000 $405,000 $267 72 days 10/31/18
28 Champlain Drive 3 3 2,417 $399,900 $399,900 $165 55 days 3/22/19
236 Mile Creek Road 4 3 3,583 $409,000 $390,000 $108 94 days 10/10/18
67 Whippoorwill Road 4 3 2,298 $389,900 $379,000 $164 0 days 12/17/18
5-1 River Road 3 3 2,282 $369,000 $375,000 $164 0 days 1/16/19
14 Wychwood Road 3 2 2,700 $379,900 $375,000 $138 0 days 10/26/18
68 Old Colony Road 8 3 2,988 $399,000 $360,000 $120 44 days 3/22/19
5-2 Oakridge Drive 3 3 2,408 $375,000 $360,000 $149 0 days 10/11/18
7 Tisbury Road 3 3 2,094 $349,000 $350,000 $167 0 days 3/22/19
26-2 Short Hills Road 4 2 2,592 $370,000 $350,000 $135 0 days 10/5/18
26 Chadwick Drive 3 2 1,735 $349,900 $344,900 $198 0 days 11/30/18
18 Jericho Drive 4 3 2,035 $359,000 $340,000 $167 62 days 1/3/19
57 Old Colony Road 3 2 1,037 $349,900 $335,000 $323 0 days 11/2/18
314 Boston Post Road 2 2 1,698 $339,000 $325,000 $191 82 days 2/5/19
308 Brightwater Road 3 1 1,088 $339,900 $315,000 $289 0 days 11/14/18
19 Flat Rock Hill Road 3 2 1,684 $324,900 $315,000 $187 0 days 10/5/18
11 Noble Avenue 3 3 1,811 $314,900 $314,900 $173 0 days 11/9/18
177 Boston Post Road 3 2 1,188 $315,900 $314,000 $264 26 days 2/14/19
22 Grassy Hill Road 3 1 1,000 $315,000 $305,000 $305 0 days 10/26/18
2 Strawberry Lane 3 2 1,944 $305,000 $304,500 $156 0 days 12/12/18
97 Whippoorwill Road 4 3 2,227 $349,000 $300,000 $134 103 days 1/22/19
33 Shore Drive 1 1 762 $300,000 $290,000 $380 0 days 12/14/18
247 Shore Road 3 2 1,250 $279,900 $284,900 $227 59 days 3/14/19
12 Walnut Road 3 1 932 $279,900 $269,900 $289 0 days 12/14/18
5 Walnut Road 4 1 1,200 $264,000 $264,000 $220 71 days 10/4/18
14 Lee Drive 3 2 1,450 $255,000 $254,500 $175 56 days 2/8/19
154 Boston Post Road 2 2 1,307 $260,000 $253,000 $193 74 days 1/16/19
49 Mccurdy Road 3 3 1,926 $279,000 $252,000 $130 0 days 11/5/18
14 Laurel Drive Unit 14 2 4 2,448 $255,000 $250,000 $102 102 days 3/4/19
128 Whippoorwill Road 3 2 1,140 $245,000 $240,000 $210 45 days 2/8/19
14 Robbin Avenue 3 1 1,352 $250,000 $240,000 $177 73 days 1/30/19
50 Rogers Lake Trail 3 2 1,576 $217,900 $230,000 $145 0 days 10/17/18
7 Jean Drive 5 3 3,173 $279,900 $225,000 $70 0 days 2/12/19
Average: 3.4 2.6 2,171 $382,496 $366,437 $186 -3 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 57
Viewing 1 - 50 of 57